(EDITOR'S NOTE: This column first appeared in the Finger Lakes Times newspaper in Geneva, NY)
By
Michael J. Fitzgerald, columnist
The Donald Trump administration may one day be remembered as the
Golden Age of full employment for lawyers.
In the 100-plus days since he took the oath of office, lawsuits
and legal motions have flown like confetti at a New York City ticker-tape
parade, keeping attorneys, judges, courts, legal staff — and the media —
scrambling to keep up.
In just the first 10 days of the administration, 41 lawsuits
were filed naming the new president. Many were related to his immigration ban.
But there were others alleging violations of the emoluments clause of the U.S.
Constitution, suits to protect sanctuary city status and others against
relaxing mining rules that will result in pollution of waterways.
Expect this tsunami of lawsuits and legal challenges to continue
for the balance of Trump’s time in the White House, possibly including an epic
legal blizzard if enough evidence is amassed to prompt Congress to vote for
impeachment.
More important than these numbers, however, is that the new
Trump administration is actually hashing out legal disputes via the legal
system.
So far, anyway.
In the first days of Trump-as-president, much of the nation held
its collective breath over whether he would try to bulldoze over the courts
claiming his presidential power trumps (pardon the pun) any challenge to his
authority.
Given his flamboyant rhetoric on the campaign trail last year,
that fear was not ungrounded.
The pivotal moment came Feb. 3 when a federal judge blocked
enforcement of a presidential executive order to implement a travel ban for
residents of seven predominantly Muslim nations.
Although the president responded to the judge’s order with
characteristically acerbic tweets, he didn’t attempt to enforce his executive
order through extralegal means that could have triggered a national crisis.
Trump’s grudging recognition of the court’s authority — again,
so far anyway — seems eerily reminiscent of staunch segregationist Alabama Gov.
George Wallace standing in an auditorium doorway in 1963 at the University of
Alabama to block the entry of two black students.
Gov. George Wallace, flanked by police |
A federal court had ruled that segregationist policies that kept
blacks from enrolling at the university were illegal.
After a long, tense confrontation Wallace, flanked by Alabama
State Police, finally stepped aside, averting a national crisis.
In the Finger Lakes, groups like Gas Free Seneca and others use
the legal system to protect the environment and promote a vision for the
region.
Those who disagree with the vision of these groups — and/or
believe many environmental safeguards are unnecessary — have their own legal
knights on the courtroom chessboards, jousting via legal argumentation.
Peaceful protests are the norm. And civil disobedience is
peaceful — and legal — too.
But 100-plus days into the new administration, there are
troubling signs the president’s legendary impatience has reached its limit,
with his legally questionable initiatives stalled under judicial review.
Adding to his frustration is that even with a heavy GOP majority
in both houses, Congress seems hapless at passing Trump-supported legislation.
In speeches and interviews, the president has been speaking ominously
about a need to consolidate power by changing legislative rules, like dumping
the filibuster.
It’s making people nervous about what might happen in a major
national emergency.
One fear is that Trump might attempt — by invoking national
security — to suspend key democratic freedoms such as the rights to peaceably
assemble, of free speech, and to have a free press.
Such a move, of course, could also suspend judicial power and
get rid of those pesky lawsuits blocking Trump’s first 100-days worth of
pending dictates.
A lot of lawyers could find themselves suddenly out of work.
And regardless whether you support the president or not, we
could all find ourselves living in an unrecognizable United States of America.
Fitzgerald worked for six newspapers as a writer and editor as
well as a correspondent for several news services. He splits his time between
Valois, NY and Pt. Richmond, Calif. You can email him at Michael.Fitzgeraldfltcolumnist@gmail.com and
visit his website at michaeljfitzgerald.blogspot.com.
Thank you for your comments. Very helpful to see it laid out succinctly.
ReplyDelete